What is Lion Tailing and Why Should You Avoid It When Pruning Trees?

Story by Rawson Services Editor / December 2, 2025

When it comes to tree trimming in Charleston, SC, one of the most harmful practices homeowners and inexperienced tree services encounter is lion tailing. Understanding proper pruning techniques versus damaging methods like lion tailing can mean the difference between a healthy, thriving tree and one that’s structurally compromised and vulnerable to storm damage.

What is Lion Tailing in Tree Pruning?

Lion tailing is an improper pruning technique where all or most of the interior branches and foliage are removed from a limb, leaving only a tuft of leaves at the end. The result looks similar to a lion’s tail—hence the name. This poor pruning practice strips away the lateral branches along the main limb, creating an unbalanced and hazardous tree structure.

Many people mistakenly believe this technique reduces weight and wind resistance, but it actually creates the opposite effect, making trees more dangerous during storms and high winds.

How Should Trees Be Pruned Correctly?

Proper tree pruning follows specific arboricultural standards that promote tree health, structural integrity, and longevity. Here’s what correct pruning looks like:

The Three-Cut Method

For larger branches, certified arborists, like Rawson Services in Charleston, SC use the three-cut method to prevent bark tearing:

  • First cut: An undercut about 12-18 inches from the trunk
  • Second cut: A top cut slightly further out that removes the branch
  • Third cut: A final cut just outside the branch collar to remove the stub

Branch Collar Preservation

The branch collar is the swollen area where a branch connects to the trunk or parent branch. Proper cuts should be made just outside this collar without leaving stubs or cutting flush against the trunk. This allows the tree to naturally seal the wound and prevent disease entry.

Selective Thinning

Rather than removing all interior growth, proper thinning removes selected branches throughout the canopy. This maintains the tree’s natural shape while:

  • Allowing light penetration to interior foliage
  • Improving air circulation
  • Reducing weight on individual limbs
  • Preserving lateral branches that provide structural support

The 25% Rule

Arborists recommend never removing more than 25% of a tree’s canopy in a single pruning session. Over-pruning stresses trees and can lead to rapid, weak regrowth.

What Are the Benefits of Proper Tree Pruning?

When done correctly by professionals, tree pruning provides numerous benefits for both the tree and property:

Structural Integrity

Proper pruning develops strong branch architecture by removing crossing branches, co-dominant leaders, and structurally weak limbs. This creates a stable framework that can withstand Charleston’s coastal storms and hurricane-force winds.

Disease Prevention

Selective pruning improves air circulation through the canopy, reducing humidity and fungal disease development. Removing dead, dying, or diseased branches prevents the spread of pathogens to healthy tissue.

Enhanced Growth

Strategic pruning redirects the tree’s energy toward healthy branches and developing leaders. This promotes vigorous growth in desired areas while maintaining the tree’s natural form.

Safety Improvement

Removing hazardous branches over structures, driveways, and walkways reduces the risk of property damage and personal injury. Regular pruning catches potential problems before they become dangerous.

Aesthetic Value

Well-pruned trees enhance curb appeal and property value. Professional trimming maintains the tree’s natural beauty while keeping it proportional to the landscape.

Clearance Management

Proper pruning provides necessary clearance from buildings, power lines, and other structures while maintaining tree health—critical for urban tree care in Charleston neighborhoods.

What Happens When Trees Are Pruned Incorrectly?

Improper pruning techniques, especially lion tailing, create serious long-term problems for trees:

Structural Failure

Lion tailing removes the lateral branches that help distribute weight and wind load along the limb. With all the foliage concentrated at the end, several problems occur:

  • Increased end weight: The weight of leaves, fruit, and snow accumulates at the tip
  • Reduced stability: Without interior branches to dampen movement, limbs whip violently in wind
  • Branch breakage: The increased leverage causes limbs to snap during storms

The result? Lion-tailed trees are significantly more likely to lose major limbs during Charleston’s summer thunderstorms and tropical weather events.

Sunscald and Bark Damage

Removing interior branches exposes bark that has been shaded for years to direct sunlight. This sudden exposure causes:

  • Sunscald (bark tissue death from heat)
  • Cracking and splitting
  • Entry points for insects and disease
  • Permanent scarring on the trunk

Water Sprout Explosion

Trees respond to over-pruning and lion tailing by producing excessive water sprouts—fast-growing vertical shoots that emerge along branches and the trunk. These sprouts are:

  • Weakly attached and prone to breaking
  • Dense and create shading problems
  • Unattractive and disrupt the tree’s form
  • Require frequent removal, increasing maintenance costs

Starvation and Decline

Foliage produces the food trees need through photosynthesis. Lion tailing removes 50-70% of a tree’s food-producing capacity, leading to:

  • Reduced vigor and growth
  • Increased susceptibility to pests and diseases
  • Dieback of branches
  • Shortened lifespan
  • Potential tree death in severe cases

Topping and Lion Tailing Combination

Often, lion tailing is combined with another harmful practice called topping (removing the top of the tree). This double-damage approach severely compromises tree health and creates hazardous conditions that persist for years.

Why Do People Lion Tail Trees?

Despite being universally condemned by certified arborists, lion tailing remains common for several reasons:

Misconceptions About Wind Resistance

Many believe that removing interior branches reduces “wind sail” effect. However, the opposite is true—concentrated foliage at branch ends catches more wind and creates greater leverage, increasing breakage risk.

Utility Line Clearance

Untrained tree trimmers may lion tail branches near power lines, thinking it provides longer-lasting clearance. Proper crown reduction or selective pruning achieves safer, longer-lasting results.

Cost-Cutting Measures

Lion tailing is faster than selective pruning, allowing inexperienced services to complete jobs quickly. This short-term saving leads to expensive long-term problems.

Lack of Training

Non-certified tree services may not understand proper pruning techniques or the long-term consequences of their methods.

How Often Should Trees Be Pruned?

The frequency of tree pruning depends on several factors:

Young Trees (1-5 years)

Structural pruning every 1-2 years establishes strong architecture and corrects problems early when corrections are easier and less costly.

Mature Trees (established growth)

Most mature trees benefit from pruning every 3-5 years. Fast-growing species like Bradford pears or silver maples may need more frequent attention.

Species-Specific Timing

Different trees have different needs:

  • Oaks: Prune during dormancy (November-March) to reduce oak wilt risk
  • Crape myrtles: Late winter before spring growth
  • Flowering trees: After blooming to avoid removing flower buds
  • Evergreens: Light pruning year-round; heavier pruning in late winter

After Storm Damage

Storm-damaged trees should be evaluated and pruned promptly to remove hazards and prevent further decline.

What Questions Should You Ask Your Tree Service?

When hiring a tree trimming company in Charleston, protect your investment by asking:

  1. Are you ISA certified arborists? Certification demonstrates knowledge of proper techniques
  2. Do you carry liability insurance and workers’ compensation? This protects you from liability
  3. What pruning techniques will you use? Avoid services that can’t explain their methods
  4. Do you follow ANSI A300 pruning standards? These are the industry best practices
  5. Will you remove more than 25% of the canopy? This is a red flag for over-pruning

If a tree service suggests lion tailing, removing most of the interior branches, or topping your trees, continue your search for a qualified professional.

Signs Your Tree Has Been Lion Tailed

If you’re unsure whether your trees have been improperly pruned, look for these warning signs:

  • Branches with bare stems and foliage only at the tips
  • Excessive water sprout growth along main limbs
  • A “poodle” or “lollipop” appearance
  • Large branches with minimal lateral branching
  • Recent branch failures despite regular trimming
  • Thinning canopy with bare interior wood visible

Trees showing these signs need corrective pruning by a certified arborist to restore proper structure over time.

The Bottom Line on Tree Pruning

Proper tree pruning is both an art and a science that requires training, experience, and understanding of tree biology. While lion tailing and other improper techniques may appear to achieve short-term goals, they create dangerous, costly long-term problems that compromise tree health and property safety.

Working with ISA certified arborists ensures your trees receive care that promotes longevity, structural integrity, and aesthetic beauty. In Charleston’s coastal environment where trees face unique stresses from salt spray, humidity, and severe weather, proper pruning techniques become even more critical for maintaining healthy, resilient landscapes.

When you invest in quality tree care, you’re not just maintaining your property’s appearance—you’re protecting valuable assets, ensuring safety, and preserving trees for future generations to enjoy.


Looking for professional tree pruning services in Charleston, SC? Contact Rawson Services , a certified arborist who follows ISA standards and best practices to ensure your trees receive the care they deserve.

 

The best tree service and the nicest people in Charleston.

— Wally Corbett – Google Review

Great service! Randy and the team called ahead to schedule, showed up right on time and did an amazing job. Thanks Rawson!

— Stewart Fife – Google Review

Task was to cut down and remove huge six foot diameter live oak that had split to the roots and half the tree had hit the ground. Randy and his crew finished most of the job on the first day and cleaned up the remainder the next day. Unbelievably professional and competent crew with top-notch equipment. I recommend his service without qualification.

— Bob Wray – Google Review

The Rawson crew is professional, quick and clean. We had them remove four large diseased oaks that were threatening structures on our property. They arrived on time and got right to work on the intricate project.

— Glenda Patron La Rue – Google Review

I had a variety of tree pruning that needed to be done surrounding my home and next to my driveway. Randy and his crew were prompt, courteous and performed expert work around the property. They cleaned up nicely and the entire service was A+. Serious pros.

— James E.

Premium Quality Badge

LICENSED & FULLY INSURED

Locally owned & operated by certified arborist.